Compare
Click the checkbox below to add an intervention for comparison
Clicking this button will open the self-assessment tool in a new window.
Key overview details
- Targeted
- Parenting
- Parent-child relationship / Attachment
- Emotion Regulation / Emotional literacy
- Infants and Toddlers: 0-36 months
- Preschool: 3 to 5 years
Attachment and Biobehavioral Catch-up
Summary
Attachment and Biobehavioral Catch-up (ABC) is a 10-session home-visiting intervention programme for parents of infants and young children 6-48 months. The ABC intervention is available for parents of infants between 6 and 24 months of age (ABC-Infant), and toddlers between 24 and 48 months (ABC-Toddler). ABC is applicable for birth parents, foster parents and adoptive parents, particularly with families at high risk for child maltreatment or adversity.
With key tenets in attachment theory and stress neurobiology, the intervention supports the development of infant and child self-regulation skills through promoting sensitive, nurturing caregiving. The key mechanism for the intervention is through ‘in the moment’ commenting on parent-child interactions, focussing on supporting parents to appropriately interpret child cues, follow the child’s lead and reduce any potentially frightening parental behaviours.
Evidence across a range of studies has identified increased secure attachment relationships between caregiver and child, improved self-regulation in children (reductions in internalising and externalising problem behaviours) and improved regulation of child’s cortisol patterns.
ABC is delivered across the US as well as in Russia, Germany, Australia, Sweden & Norway. ABC has not yet been implemented in the UK.
Website: http://www.abcintervention.org/
Core Components
The ABC intervention is available for parents of infants between 6 and 24 months of age (ABC-Infant), and toddlers between 24 and 48 months (ABC-Toddler). ABC has shown benefits for any child living with or at risk for maltreatment, although the most long-term evidence relates to children living with their birth parents who have experienced or who are at high risk of experiencing child maltreatment or adversity.
The ABC programme is home-delivered over 10 weekly 1-hour sessions. The programme is clearly operationalised, with each session content outlined. There are three key targets to the intervention, namely ‘nurturance’ (which includes reinterpretation of child cues and not instinctively responding ‘in kind’ to seemingly rejecting responses from the child), ‘following the child’s lead with delight’ and ‘not being frightening’. The toddler version includes the additional target of ‘calming a dysregulated toddler’ with caregivers described as ‘coregulators’. The key component of the intervention in addressing these targets is specific ‘in the moment’ comments on the parent-child interactions.
Fidelity
ABC has rigorous fidelity monitoring tools integral to programme delivery. Parent coaches must submit weekly videotapes of intervention delivery which are measured in their adherence to programme content as well as frequency and quality of ‘in the moment’ comments. Weekly monitoring takes place for the first year post-training and fidelity must be demonstrated over this period for a practitioner to be recognised as delivering the evidence-based model.
The programme acknowledges the potential time and financial burdens of this fidelity process, and explores this with agencies prior to engagement, however they also highlight that agencies can be assured they can expect to receive the outcomes which have been evidenced and that parent coaches receive the benefits of personalised, detailed feedback on their delivery practice.
Modifiable Components
The programme was originally designed for foster carers and went on to be shown to have evidence of effectiveness for birth parents and adoptive parents. The initial infant intervention (6-24 months) was modified to include toddler populations and include the challenge of parenting a dysregulated toddler.
As testified by the rigorous fidelity measures, the programme is evidence based when implemented in full, without modifications.
Initial training in ABC-Infant takes place in-person and lasts for 2 days. Training for smaller groups is held bi-annually at the University of Delaware. Trainers will travel to the training site for larger groups.
Support for Organisation/Practice
Implementation Support
Implementation support for initial engagement and ongoing delivery is provided by Dr Caroline Roben, Director of Dissemination for ABC. The programme is also currently developing a Webinar resource to support agencies with effective set-up and implementation.
The programme does not have any mandatory data collection in place, however they have recommended measures if agencies wish to be involved with programme evaluation data collection.
Start-up Costs
Cost of initial ABC Infant interview, 2-day training, weekly supervision and fidelity tracking for a year, with administrative support, is $7,000 per person.
Following certification in the Infant programme, the cost for ABC Toddler initial interview, half-day training, weekly supervision and fidelity tracking for a year, with administrative costs, is $5,000 per person.
Training costs include a year of weekly clinical and fidelity monitoring. If any additional weekly fidelity supervision is desired or required, this priced at $200/month.
Building Staff Competency
Qualifications Required
Parent Coaches for training are identified through a 30-minute interview, in which the characteristics screened for have been demonstrated to correlate with later number and quality of ‘in the moment’ comments.
There are no specific qualifications required to be trained in ABC and although the majority of Parent Coaches hold a Masters in Social Work degree, there are also certified nurses, home visiting practitioners, teachers and parents who have themselves gone through the programme.
Training Requirements
Individuals selected through screening to go on to Parent Coach training undergo a 2-day training followed by a year of supervision and fidelity monitoring. Training includes theoretical and practical orientation to the intervention, practice with “In the Moment” commenting and coding, review of session content, consultation concerning site-specific implementation, and planning for the supervision year.
Additional training is required for the toddler programme once certified in the infant programme, which is theoretically another year of twice weekly supervision, however in practice fidelity can be achieved more quickly for skilled, experienced practitioners.
Supervision Requirements
Parent Coach Trainees have 2 obligatory supervision meetings per week for their year of training: General Clinical Supervision (1 hour) and ‘In the Moment’ Commenting Supervision (30 min). Supervision is conducted using video conferencing. The time commitment for session preparation, visit, and supervision is approximately 4 hours per case each week. The cost of this supervision is included in total training costs.
Certified Parent Coaches with high level of fidelity to model can go on to train as Supervisors. For the cost of training in supervision, supervision fidelity training, or training in training, interested sites should contact the developers for creating plans of sustainability.
ABC has consistently demonstrated across RCTs, sustained improvements in child attachment security, child self-regulation and normalised child cortisol patterns.
Theory of Change
Mechanism of change focuses on enhancing caregiver nurturance and ability to follow the child’s lead, with improved sensitivity as a key mediator, through ‘in the moment’ comments, which promote a more organised, secure attachment between caregiver and child, improved regulation of child cortisol production and improved child self-regulation of emotions and behaviours.
Infants and Toddlers: 0-36 months - Rating: 5
Number of Research Studies & Research Design
Multiple (10+) rigorous Randomised Control Trials and extensive further analyses of these samples have been undertaken. RCTs have been conducted by independent research groups as well as by those affiliated with the programme.
Systematic Review (Grube & Liming, 2018) identified 10 papers (relating to 3 original RCTs and analyses following these) with specific child outcomes.
Outcomes Achieved
Child Outcomes
Children with high risk of multiple adversities, whose parents or foster parents received ABC intervention, have demonstrated (in many cases over a number of studies):
- Higher rates of secure attachment and lower rates of disorganised attachment relative to control groups (Bernard et al., 2012). Current research (in preparation) suggests improved attachment status is maintained at 8 year follow up.
- Improved self-regulation with reductions in externalising and internalising problem behaviours (e.g. Lind et al., 2014).
- Normalised patterns of cortisol production, regulation and recovery, mediated by parental sensitivity (e.g. Berlin et al., 2019).
- Long term (8 year follow up) positive impact on neural function (Bick et al., 2018) and autonomic regulation (Tabachnick et al., 2019).
- Significantly enhanced toddler compliance (Lind et al., 2019).
- Positive impact on cognitive development including language skills (e.g. Bernard et al., 2017).
All above outcomes relate to children of families who received the original version of ABC which maps on to the current ABC-Infant programme. Two recent RCTs of ABC-Toddler specifically have demonstrated:
- Advanced receptive vocabulary skills at least 1-year post-intervention, mediated by improved parental sensitivity (Raby et al. 2018).
- Enhanced executive function at 48 months (Lind et al., 2017).
Parent Outcomes
- Parents who have participated in ABC have consistently demonstrated improved parental sensitivity, increased positive affect and reduced intrusiveness, compared with control intervention parents (Bick & Dozier, 2013; Yarger et al., 2018).
Key Reference
Grube, W. & Liming, K. (2018). Attachment and Biobehavioral Catch-up: A Systematic Review. Infant Mental Health Journal, 39(6), 656-673.
Preschool: 3 to 5 years - Rating: 4
Research Design & Number of Studies
ABC-Toddler version is targeted at parents/caregivers of children age 24-48 months. One recent internal Randomised Control Trial (RCT) has been conducted for ABC-Toddler with outcomes applicable to this 3-5 year old population.
Outcomes Achieved
Child Outcomes
• Lind et al. (2017) demonstrate enhanced executive function at 48 months in those children whose parents/caregivers had received ABC-Toddler intervention.
References
Lind, T., Raby, K.L., Caron, E., Roben, C.K.P., & Dozier, M. (2017). Enhancing executive functioning among toddlers in foster care with an attachment-based intervention. Development and Psychopathology, 29, 575-586.
Values
The core values of the ABC programme are to develop infant and child self-regulation skills through promoting sensitive, nurturing caregiving.
- Is the delivery of this type of work considered to be in keeping with the core practice of these practitioners?
Priorities
ABC is targeted towards families at high risk of child maltreatment or multiple adversities, with the aim to improve the parent-child relationship and impact on positive child and parent outcomes.
- Is working with parents of babies and young children in a home-visiting early intervention approach a priority for your organisation?
- Is the delivery of targeted services to families of infants and young children at high risk for maltreatment aligned with the key values and priorities of your organisation?
Existing Initiatives
- Does your service already provide early intervention programmes aiming to improve child development and mental health outcomes?
Workforce
ABC practitioners are selected through an interview process to assess their reflective capacity and potential for delivering the programme with fidelity.
- Do your practitioner(s) have experience in working with infants, young children and their families?
- Are your practitioners able to work with a sensitive, reflective approach?
ABC recommend that practitioners implement ABC over 10-weeks with at least 2 families at a time and ideally, with 50% of their overall caseload. In addition, practitioners are required to attend supervision and coaching for up to 1.5 hours per week with another half hour for fidelity coding for at least their first year of implementation.
- Does your agency have capacity for practitioner(s) to work with ABC with at least 2 families at a time and ideally, with 50% of their caseload?
- Will your practitioner(s) have protected time (1.5 hours/week for at least 1 year, with 30 minutes for fidelity coding) to prepare for and attend supervision and coaching with ABC supervisors?
Technology Support
ABC requires practitioners to capture and upload videos of their practice for review in supervision. Practitioners also need access to Zoom to facilitate supervision.
- Do you have the technology to support practitioners to access these tools necessary for effective supervision?
Administrative Support
ABC will require some administrative support in preparing materials and collecting any appropriate data.
- Do your current administrative procedures support your practitioners to implement a programme like this?
Financial Support
The cost of ABC initial interview, 2-day training, weekly supervision and fidelity tracking for a year and administrative support is $7,000. Any additional weekly fidelity supervision which is desired or required is priced at $200/month.
- Do you have the finances to pay for practitioners to attend the initial interview and training?
- Do you have the finances to support any additional fidelity monitoring if required?
In addition, there will be running costs for materials – worksheets and handouts as well as toys and other delivery tools - travel expense for home visits and technology costs to be able to capture and review video footage.
- Do you have the finances to pay for the printing of worksheets, leaflets and handouts for the delivery of the programme?
Comparable Population
ABC is targeted at birth and foster families with children 6-48 months old, experiencing or at high risk of experiencing maltreatment or adversity.
- Is this an identified population of particular concern to your organisation?
Desired outcome
ABC aims to improve children’s social and emotional development through nurturing the parent-child relationship and outcomes have demonstrated higher rates of secure attachment, improved child self-regulation and increased parental sensitivity.
- Are the improvements of children’s social and emotional development, learning and mental health priority outcomes for your organisation?
- Do you have other existing initiatives that would be supportive of addressing this need and achieving these outcomes?
Caroline Roben (Director of Dissemination): croben@psych.udel.edu