We use cookies to ensure that we provide you with the best possible experience on our website. More information on the cookies we set can be found in our privacy policy.

I'm okay with this
Glossary

Compare

Click the checkbox below to add an intervention for comparison


Complete assessment

Clicking this button will open the self-assessment tool in a new window.

Key overview details

Classification
  • Universal
  • Targeted
Mental Wellbeing Need
  • Parenting
  • Parent-child relationship / Attachment
Target Age
  • Infants and Toddlers: 0-36 months
  • Preschool: 3 to 5 years
Provision
  • Show only programmes known to have been implemented in Scotland
Usability Rating
4
Supports Rating
3
Evidence Rating
3 - 4+
Share

Circle of Security Parenting: COSP

Summary

Circle of Security Parenting (COSP) is a programme for parents of children 4 months to 6 years that is delivered in groups, or to individuals or couples. It is designed for all parents and caregivers, but is frequently delivered to high risk and highly vulnerable families. It is an 8-week reflective education group, based on attachment theory. During each session, using video vignettes, and the Circle of Security graphic, caregivers are introduced to a concept of the theory. They are then prompted to observe the concept in action and reflect on what they have seen. Research has shown that attending COSP is associated with improvements in the child-caregiver interactions. Overall the programme aims to enhance security in child-parent relationships, which is associated with improved child outcomes. It is an adaptation of the Circle of Security Intensive programme. COSP is delivered across the US, in Europe, and is currently delivered within Scotland.

Website: https://www.circleofsecurityinternational.com/

Usability - Rating: 4

Core Components

Circle of Security Parenting (COSP) is designed for parents of young children, 4 months to 6 years. In particular, it is aimed at parents who would benefit from support to recognise and improve their relationship with their child. The programme can be used for high risk and highly vulnerable families, often as an entry point to a wider programme of support and intervention, offered by the implementing organisation.

COSP is an 8-session educational group programme which uses video vignettes, reflective questions posed by a trained facilitator and a series of graphics including the Circle of Security graphic to introduce attachment theory in an accessible manner. Each session introduces a concept of the theory, and then caregivers are prompted to observe the concept in action within a video clip and reflect on what they have seen. Using the Circle Security graphic caregivers learn about providing a secure base from which their child can explore, and a safe haven to which their child can return. The key message to caregivers is that their role is “Always: be BIGGER, STRONGER, WISER, and KIND. Whenever possible, follow your child’s need and whenever necessary, take charge.”

COSP is clearly operationalised. It is a manualised programme, where each session is highly structured, with detailed instructions on content and managing the group processes. Animations, video clips and handouts articulate key messages of the programme. It is an adaptation of Circle of Security Intensive program, specifically designed to be implemented widely and easily. Handouts have been written using clear and simple language, and require minimal literacy skills.

Fidelity

The core features are clearly defined. The programme needs to be delivered as a minimum of 8 sessions of 90 minutes, over a period of a minimum of 8 weeks. Additional sessions can be added to cover the topics, but the programme must not be compressed. Fidelity is managed by adherence to the manual. In addition, COSP has a reflective Fidelity Journal. Fidelity coaching is available, at different levels of intensity, including video review.

Modifiable Components

COSP is a modified version of the COS Intensive programme. COSP can be delivered in group format, or with individuals or couples. COSP can also be delivered to other caregivers such as foster carers, or childminders. Video footage is available with British English narration. The programme can be delivered in more, but not fewer than 8 sessions. Materials have been translated in to other languages. In order to maintain fidelity, further modification of the components of the programme is not supported.

Supports - Rating: 3

Circle of Security International is based in the US. Circle of Security Parenting training is offered within the UK and can be delivered on site.

Support for Organisation/Practice

Implementation Support

On completion of training, practitioners have access to a manual which includes detailed session plans and handouts. They also receive the 8-session narrated video. On the members section of the Circle of Security International website, further resources are available including a fidelity journal and tip videos on implementation.

For additional cost, fidelity coaching is available at a range of levels to support practitioner development. There is a programme to support practitioners become fidelity coaches.

Licence Requirements

There are no licence requirements.

Start-up Costs.

Cost are limited to initial training (approx. $1000 USD per place), and the costs for equipment for showing video clips if this is not already available. Optional fidelity coaching costs start at $540 USD per practitioner for a nine-session initial level coaching programme.

Building Staff Competency

Qualifications Required

Practitioners need to have experience working with parents of young children. There are no set qualifications or specific prerequisites for training. The programme outlines the key competencies for practitioners which includes ability to understand and model the key concepts of the programme. They need to be able to manage the group and recognise issues that may be raised such as disclosure of trauma.

Training Requirements

Training consists of four days of face-to-face training. It is regularly offered in the UK and can be commissioned for on-site delivery. Training includes all the materials required to run the programme and access to the facilitators section of the website.

Supervision Requirements

Specific COSP supervision is not mandated. Practitioners will require access to reflective supervision. Practitioners can complete a fidelity journal. Circle of Security International offers a fidelity coaching programme.

Evidence - Rating: 3 - 4+

Theory of Change

COSP has an explicit logic model based on knowledge and theory about attachment and the link between secure attachment as a protective factor for child development. It has the long term goal of enhancing secure attachment between caregivers and children. The mechanism by which the program intends to deliver these outcomes is:

• Demonstrate, using video review, an attachment-based model of children’s developmental needs emphasising the role of the caregiver in an accessible manner.
• Develop caregivers’ skills in observing this model in action.
• Help caregivers reflect on their own actions in meeting (or not) the needs of their child.
• Promote reflection of caregivers’ own experience of parenting and how this influences them.
• Provide caregivers an experience of a secure base in the group.
• Co-regulate caregivers’ emotional experiences through facilitation by a trained provider.
• Promote caregivers to reflect on how they co-regulate their children’s emotional experiences.

Through these mechanisms, the programme aims for caregivers to develop more reflective and empathetic responses to their child.

Infants and Toddlers: 0-36 months - Rating: 3

Research Design & Number of Research Studies

One randomised controlled trial which included, but was not limited to, parents with children age 0-36 months and included a child outcome was identified.  This was conducted independently of the programme originators.

Outcomes Achieved

Attendance at Circle of Security Parenting, in addition to standard treatment was associated with:

Child outcome

  • Significantly improved child-caregiver interaction from baseline to 12-month follow-up.

Parent outcome

  • Significant increase in emotionally available interactions, which were maintained at follow-up.
  • In the COSP group, from baseline to the 12 months follow-up, there was a significant increase number of caregivers that had a balanced narrative of their child. That is that caregivers were able to think of their child as having its own thoughts, feelings, intentions and desires in a coherent way. (There was no significant change for parents in the control group).  
  • There were non-significant improvements with the control group, and there were not significant differences in any outcome between the COSP group and controls.

Reference

Mothander, PR., Furmark, C, & Neander, K. (2018). Adding “Circle of Security -Parenting” to treatment as usual in three Swedish infant mental health clinics. Effects on parents’ internal representations and quality of parent-infant interaction. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 59(3), 262-272.

Preschool: 3 to 5 years - Rating: 4+

Research Design & Number of Studies

One randomised controlled trial (RCT) which was conducted with parents with children aged 3-5 years was identified.  This was conducted independently of the programme originators. In addition, the evidence presented above included parents of children aged 3-5, and remains relevant. 

Outcomes Achieved

In addition to the outcomes already stated, attendance at Circle of Security Parenting, in comparison with waiting list control was associated with:

Child outcome

  • Significantly increased inhibitory control. 

Parent outcome

  • Significant change in maternal response to child distress, with fewer unsupportive behaviours.

Reference 

Cassidy, J., Brett, B., Gross, JT., et al. (2017). Circle of Security-Parenting: A randomized control trial in Head Start.  Development and Psychopathology 29, 651-673

Fit

Values

The Circle of Security Parenting (COSP) programme focuses on the importance of understanding attachment to support child wellbeing, using a structured approach.

  • Does this align with the key values of your organisation?

Priorities

  • Is working with parents of babies and young children in an early intervention approach a priority for your organisation?
  • If your service is providing support to highly vulnerable families, would COSP fit as part a wider intervention package?

Existing Initiatives

  • Does your service already provide early intervention programmes aiming to improve child development and mental health outcomes?
  • Do you have links with CAMHS, Adult Mental Health Services and Child Protection Services to refer onto if required?
Capacity

Workforce

The Circle of Security Parenting programme requires a trained practitioner to deliver this programme weekly over 8 weeks. Facilitators are encouraged to follow up with caregivers who miss any sessions. The practitioner needs to be able to understand and communicate the key concepts of attachment as outlined in the programme, have experience working with parents of young children, and be able to manage any disclosures of trauma or mental health difficulties and appropriately direct for additional support. Practitioners delivering COSP require access to regular reflective supervision.

  • Do you have practitioner with appropriate experience and competencies?
  • Can your organisation protect time needed for training, delivery and supervision for these practitioners?
  • Can your organisation provide supervision for practitioners?

Technology Support

Showing video clips, either by playing a DVD, inserting a USB drive or streaming the material from the web is integral to the programme.

  • Do you have facilities to deliver this?

Administrative Support

  • Do your current administrative procedures support your practitioners to implement a group parenting programme?
  • Do you have access to a group room with suitable technology support for group delivery?
  • Do you have administrative procedures that can support attendance, such as reminders?

Financial Support

Training to deliver Circle of Security Parenting costs $1000 and includes the required materials. Optional fidelity coaching costs from $540 per practitioner, for the initial level of the coaching programme.

  • Do you have the finances to pay for practitioners to attend this training?
  • Do you have the finances to support fidelity coaching?

In addition, there will be running costs for materials such as printing of worksheets, leaflets and handouts. Attendance at groups can be supported by the provision childcare, food and transport.

  • Do you have the finances to pay for theses running costs?
Need

Comparable Population

Circle of Security Parenting (COSP) is a programme for parents of young children, where parents would benefit from greater understanding of attachment behaviours. It can be delivered as a universal programme, or to more vulnerable groups as part of a wider package of care.

  • Do you have sufficient demand for an attachment focused parenting intervention to sustain a group or individual delivery of COSP?

Desired Outcome

Circle of Security Parenting programme aims for caregivers to develop more reflective and emphatic responses to their child, and therefore improve the child-caregiver relationships and attachment security.

  • Are the improvements in child-caregiver relationships a priority for your organisation?
  • Do you have other existing initiatives that would be supportive of addressing this need and achieving these outcomes?